This is a complex set of reforms the Government intends to implement in stages over the next three years.
The first stage was the Water Services Regulator Act - which created the water services regulator ‘Taumata Arowai’. This body will oversee and enforce a new drinking water regulatory framework, and have oversight of the management of our wastewater and stormwater networks. This is designed to ensure that minimum water standards are met no matter who the supplier. This new Crown entity is currently being established, and will become responsible for drinking water regulation when the second stage, the Water Services Bill, is passed, which is expected to be mid-2021.
The third stage is the establishment of new ‘water services entities’. These would require the councils transfer their water infrastructure and delivery services to a small number of multi-regional entities. The Government believes that a small number of entities covering a larger area of population will mean smaller communities could realise the benefits of scale, and that the larger entities would have a big enough asset base to be able to borrow to scale.
Currently the Government is consulting with stakeholders - the stakeholders nominated by the Government for this engagement process being local government and iwi/hapū - on their methodology and progress in working out the boundaries and size for each entity, and requesting feedback on a range of options for governance and ownership models.
Let's look at the ‘water services entities’ proposal.
ENTITY SIZE AND BOUNDARIES: The Government has yet to decide on the proposed number, size or boundary of each entity. In late 2020 they issued a request for information to councils in order to establish the current state of water infrastructure, current service delivery arrangements, and future plans including upgrades. This information will allow the government to complete this stage of the reform.
As a result of the data provided by the councils the Government recently released an interim assessment report. This includes a recalculation of the original estimation of the investment needed over the next 30 - 40 years to maintain and enhance existing infrastructure and add build infrastructure to meet growth requirements. This amount has risen to a new figure of between $110 billion - $170 billion. (p.10 ‘Three Waters Reform Programme IPWEA Webinar 24 March 2021’).
The data has also caused the government to reconsider whether the infrastructure for stormwater would be better to stay under the management of local councils "as this is an extremely complex area that needs more thought".
ENTITY OWNERSHIP MODELS: The Government has explicitly stated that there will be a bottom line of public ownership and that there will be mechanisms in place to ensure the entities cannot be privatised in the future. However, the Government will also consider options for Crown and iwi/Māori interests in the new water services entities. This is mentioned in the Cabinet Minute of Decision ‘Progressing the Three Waters Service Delivery Reforms’ (clause 21), without any other information to clarify this option - other than the mention of a potential for delivery partnerships in the Three waters Reform Programme - Local Government and Iwi/hapū engagement document (p.68).
ENTITY GOVERNANCE MODELS: During March the Government undertook engagement workshops with local government, and also with iwi/hapu groups. These workshops were held to present the Government’s latest thinking on details of the reform proposals.
According to the presentation, based on the Local Government and Iwi/hapū engagement consultation document, the water services entities would be overseen by a board of directors. Various structures for governance are being explored. Options include:
- A ‘base’ structure with shared local authority and mana whenua governance
- A high degree of involvement by local authorities, mana whenua included in governance arrangements
- A low degree of involvement by local authorities, mana whenua included in governance arrangements
Please see the proposed models diagrammed below:
The government claims that the reform programme is being progressed through a voluntary partnership-based approach with the local government sector, who can choose to opt out before the end of 2021 deadline. Whether this is true is yet to be seen - cabinet documents and a briefing to Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta appear to indicate councils could be made to relinquish their water services to the new entities if too few opt into the proposed restructure voluntarily.
Constitutional change by stealth
The governance options outlined in the Three Waters Reform Programme Local Government and Iwi/hapū engagement document are profoundly undemocratic. The proposed models for the Water Services Entities are even further removed from public accountability than what we currently have in place. The board members would be given the power to decide when and where infrastructure would be built and maintained, have the ability to set and impose water rates, and to oversee the allocation and reallocation of water supplies as they see fit, with virtually no way for the general public to influence these decisions. Government documents speak of the possibility of processes for public consultation, but under the models proposed there would be no direct accountability to the public, nor any way for the public to influence policy and direction, such as by voting for members of the board.
On the other hand the proposals are loaded with provision for iwi/Maori participation. Mana whenua would have as much authority to appoint members to the Water Services Board as Local Authorities. With the second model it appears mana whenua are in the driving seat - supplemented by an ‘etc’, (whatever that means - see diagram p.68). Additionally, mana whenua are singled out for direct involvement - the proposals include mechanisms to enable each Iwi/Māori in the area covered by the Water Services Entity to directly influence outcomes, and be funded to do so. (See p.34 for an indication of tribal boundaries).
And then there are provisions relating to the obligation requiring anyone who has functions or duties under the legislation to give effect to Te Mana o te Wai (Clause 14 of the Water Services Bill).Te Mana o te Wai is described by Minister Mahuta as a whole-of-system approach to the management of our water that recognises the Maori worldview and knowledge. (Please note that if a decision maker is required to “give effect to” something, it must be utilised, implemented or followed).
Also of great concern is the nebulous nature of Te Mana o te Wai - it is a concept that is flexible and lacks clarity. Therefore, the requirement that “all persons who perform or exercise functions, powers, and duties under the legislation to give effect to Te Mana o te Wai” is an edict immersed in uncertainty. Under this clause the water services suppliers would be vulnerable to arbitrary directives, an undesirable situation which contravenes an important principle of law i.e certainty in law.
Such provisions institute major constitutional change, but……..
……...THERE IS ANOTHER WAY!
Firstly, our local bodies do not have to take up the option of shifting the responsibility for water services and delivery from themselves to the more centralised model as proposed by the Government. Secondly, if they decide to do so we do not have to lose the democratic control of our water. We can keep a level of public accountability by allowing the public to have a say over the governance of these entities. Just as we vote for local and community boards and licensing trusts etc, we could also vote for Water Boards. By doing so we can ensure that the public interest is at the centre of decision-making. This is also a far more robust way to keep the entities in public ownership, rather than the models the government is proposing.
WHAT YOU CAN DO
The Government is due to release a public consultation document on its proposals for the water service entities in mid-2021. In the meantime, you can contact your mayor and councillors to let them know that you are not happy to see an unelected, undemocratic board take control of the water services delivery and infrastructure in your area. Petition them to ensure that democracy is built into these proposed entities. Chances are many of them are not happy with the proposals either and just need to know that they have the backing of their community.
You can find councillor contact details HERE.
Below is our suggested wording, please feel free to change.
I am writing to you about the Government’s Three Waters Reform Programme. According to a Department of Internal Affairs report, ‘Central/Local Government Three Waters Reform Programme’, councils and their communities are to make decisions on remaining in or opting out of the reform programme. I wish to voice my opinion about aspects of this programme, such as the following.
- Under the Government’s planned service delivery reforms, water services would no longer be under the control of the council and would instead be operated by a small number of publicly owned multi-regional entities. I am concerned that this would result in citizens having virtually no influence over our water supply, nor the opportunity to elect who is responsible for controlling it.
- While there is specific mention of mechanisms to recognise the interests of iwi/Māori, with “more direct mechanisms for iwi/Māori to influence outcomes with clearer accountabilities,” there is no specific mechanism to incorporate and maintain the voice of communities in the new system design.
- I have read the Government’s Three Waters Reform Programme discussion document and have grave concerns about the high level of authority afforded iwi/ Māori over the establishment of water service entities and delivery of water services. I want decisions over the control, allocation, and delivery of water services to remain accountable to our democratically elected councillors – rather than vested interests.
For these reasons I am urging you to vote to opt out the reform programme as proposed by the Government.
FURTHER INFORMATION & REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
Department of Internal Affairs: The Waters Reform
Taumata Arowai - Frequently Asked Questions
Progressing the three waters service delivery reforms, December 2020
Three waters Steering Committee Update - 25 February 2021
Three Waters Reform Programme Local Government and Iwi/hapū engagement, March 2021
Centralisation of water services: Nanaia Mahuta, RNZ Nine To Noon, 16 Mar 2021
This is a complex set of reforms, and the piecemeal approach to the legislation makes it difficult to see the full picture. To make it easier to understand, we've created a page dedicated to the Three Waters Reform that explains the process to date, what's next and how to have your say. Please feel free to share this page with your friends and family so that they are informed too.