< August 2022 newsletter


PROFESSOR JAMES ALLAN ANALYSIS OF HE PUAPUA NOW AVAILABLE

Towards the end of 2012 Democracy Action commissioned Professor James Allan, of the University of Queensland, to produce an analysis of the He Puapua Report  - a report that calls for highly controversial constitutional change. Specifically, we sought Professor Allan’s opinion on the implications for New Zealand’s liberal democracy in adopting recommendations made in He Puapua, and what this would mean for the future of New Zealand.

After studying He Puapua, James concludes that:

“This is a radical Report. Its recommendations are radical. Were those recommendations to be fulfilled to any considerable degree they would undercut majoritarian democracy; they would impinge upon elements of the Rule of Law; and they would exchange newer, worse, more aristocratic constitutional arrangements for older, better, more democratic ones.”

To read James’s written report in full please click HERE.

To coincide the release of Professor Allan’s report, he was invited to New Zealand to speak at public meetings in Auckland and Christchurch, and at a function at the Beehive. This was done in the knowledge that far too many people know very little about He Puapua and are unaware of the stealthy way it is being implemented. His visit also gave us the opportunity to question and publicly debate the damage the Government’s divisive and separatist policies are doing to our democracy.

The public meetings were well attended, at which we were privileged to listen to James’s informative and entertaining presentations. Some key points made by James included:

  • There is no doubt He Puapua is a radical prescription for undermining democracy and the rule of law.
  • New Zealand’s current constitution is based on parliamentary sovereignty. But He Puapua advocates overturning our constitution in favour of one in which the Treaty of Waitangi and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) are wedged into a European-style written constitution with strong judicial review at its heart. This will inevitably make a committee of unelected top judges immensely powerful.
  • He Puapua strongly pushes a co-governance or partnership model of governing.
  • At the heart of all the co-governance models is race-based or ethnic-based identity politics, in this instance one where one group represents about 15 per cent of the population and the other everyone else.
  • Group rights take precedence over individual rights.
  • He Puapua’s race based political mode will add further to divisions in our society.

For more, please listen to a video recording of Professor Allan’s presentation, available HERE.

You are welcome to share this link with your friends and families.

For more on James Allan’s analysis of He Puapua, visit our website HERE. This includes links to recordings of interviews James had with Leighton Smith, Michael Laws for The Platform, and Dr Oliver Hartwich (NZ Initiative).

Go back to the August 2022 newsletter


RELATED ARTICLES


Minister Jackson working to adopt UNDRIP

The next step in the process to develop a plan for New Zealand to implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) was kicked off last month with a targeted engagement strategy aimed at ensuring as many Māori voices as possible get to share their views on what should be included in a Declaration plan. Continue reading

'Others' not consulted on Declaration Plan

Photo: Andrew Little, Nanaia Mahuta, Jacinda Ardern, Kelvin Davis and David Parker at the 2018 National Iwi Chairs Forum. Alarm bells are ringing after Māori leaders expressed monumental ambitions during initial discussions with the Government about how to recognise the highly controversial United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). The Minister for Māori Development, Willie Jackson, says those discussions will shape the Government’s Declaration plan.  Continue reading

The campaign to implement UNDRIP continues

An associate professor at the University of Auckland Law School, Dr Claire Charters, is currently working on articles on the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), the relationship between tikanga Māori and the state legal system, tensions between human rights and indigenous peoples' rights and on the legitimacy of indigenous peoples' rights under international law, which will be published as a book by Cambridge University Press.  Continue reading

Plan underway to implement UNDRIP

The Ministry of Maori Development, is developing a plan to progress the implementation of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Given the serious implications of this declaration, and the adoption of an engagement process with iwi, hapū and whānau, but not the wider community, the government needs to hear from us. Continue reading

Margaret Mutu pushing for implementation of UNDRIP

Margaret Mutu, current leader of the Iwi Chairs Forum, is pushing for the implementation of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, (UNDRIP), claiming the Minister for Maori Development, Nanaia Mahuta, is supportive. See media release ‘Iwi Pleased with Government Decision to Develop a Plan of Action for Indigenous Rights’ and listen to a Waatea News interview with MUTU by clicking HERE Continue reading