< December 2020 newsletter

Stuff’s ‘brave new era’ – goodbye to independence and objectivity

The backbone of any democracy is an independent, objective, and responsible media. But the Stuff media organisation is eschewing this value system to undertake a ‘reset’. This includes a new company charter with Te Tiriti o Waitangi embedded at its core.

According to Stuff chief executive Sinead Boucher, “Our people advocated for the Treaty principles of partnership, participation and protection to be embedded in our new strategy”.

“Our wish is to be a trusted partner for tangata whenua for generations to come.”

Boucher needs to explain how Stuff can live up to its claim of trusted independent journalism when it is choosing to become beholden to a ‘Treaty partner’.

One of the first casualties of this policy has been the refusal of two Stuff publications, the Whangarei Leader and the Bay Chronicle, to publish an advertisement from Democracy Northland. They did so despite the advert being cleared by the Advertising Standards Authority as being factually correct, and despite the editors of each of the two publications initially accepting the ad, with Stuff confirming the booking and accepting payment. The advertisement is about democracy and did not go into the merits or otherwise of race-based seats. See for yourself – the ad is available by clicking HERE

People of Northland, please share the advertisement with as many people as possible. Additionally, we can all send messages to Stuff to voice our concerns about the nature of their ‘reset’. The contact details are:

Stuff Editor in Chief

Patrick Crewdson

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @PatrickCrewdson

We could ask for an explanation of their policy. Will they be employing Māori vetting officers? Will they only publish articles that have been “approved”? Will they be emulating the example of the Auckland Council, which has developed the following responses to meet its commitment to the Treaty?

  • A Māori Responsiveness Framework; and
  • Māori impact statements in council decision-making reports; and
  • agreements with iwi that provide greater opportunity to contribute to and influence decision-making.

See: Governance manual - Auckland Council obligations

Media coverage

Breaking Views: Democracy Northland: The Ad Stuff Refused to Publish

Stuff: Our Truth, Tā Mātou Pono: Stuff introduces new Treaty of Waitangi based charter following historic apology


Go back to the December 2020 newsletter


Powerful regulator proposed for online services, social media platforms

Consultation is now open on a proposed approach to regulating online services and media platforms in New Zealand. You can read more about the background to this work on the Department of Internal Affairs (DIA) website HERE, which includes links to the discussion document and supporting information. Continue reading

Willie Jackson’s new media empire causes concern

More than 800 submissions have been received on the Government’s Aotearoa New Zealand Public Media Bill, a law that will merge TVNZ and RNZ under a new parent group. A number of media executives, including from TVNZ and RNZ, are expressing concerns about the lack of protection for editorial independence of the proposed new public media entity - that the bill would give the Government far greater control over public media than it has at the moment. Continue reading

Fears raised about government control of new public media entity

Independent media, free of government influence, is vital to a well-functioning democracy. The media must be able to hold government officials accountable, raise controversial issues without fear of reprisal, and include a diversity of voices and opinions, not just those that politicians want covered. However, the legislation to merge RNZ and TVNZ - the Aotearoa New Zealand Public Media Bill - is raising fears that our new public media entity - ‘Aotearoa New Zealand Public Media’ will result in opportunities for political interference. Continue reading

The corruption of the mainstream media

Most mainstream news organisations are making hundreds of thousands, if not millions of dollars a year, off the new Public Interest Journalism Fund. The Public Interest Journalism Fund is a $55m government grant handed out to news media organisations by the Labour government, via NZ On Air.  Continue reading