Anthony Willy: The State Owned Enterprises Case and the Partnership Fiction
On a plain reading of the treaty document anything less conducive to the notion of a partnership between the signatories is difficult to imagine. It is therefore necessary to look elsewhere to find what breathes life into this myth. No recourse can be had to International law because the document is not a treaty. International law only recognizes compacts entered into by sovereign states. Those inhabitants signing did not exercise sovereignty of these Islands in 1840. That they did not sign as Sovereigns of New Zealand is clear beyond doubt because a number refused to do so including the representatives of the Ngapuhi tribe.
Continue reading
Gary Judd KC: the Treaty of Waitangi and the Prospect of a Referendum
VIDEO: Michael Laws speaks to Gary Judd KC about the Treaty of Waitangi and the prospect of a referendum. Click here to view.
Continue reading
Elizabeth Rata: Two Treaties of Waitangi: The Articles Treaty and the Principles Treaty
There are two versions of the Treaty of Waitangi. The first is the 1840 Treaty – the ‘Articles Treaty’. The second is what I call the ‘Principles Treaty’. It dates from 1986 when the principles were first included in legislation. Astonishingly the parliamentary representatives who inserted the word ‘principles’ did not know what they meant. To include a word estranged from its meaning into legislation is an egregious political failure. At the very least, a democracy requires words to have an agreed meaning otherwise rational communication is impossible. Autocracies that use ideologies to control how people think can dispense with accurate meaning. Democracies cannot.
Continue reading
Bob Edlin: Jackson and the Treaty
Jackson and the Treaty – it seems he has forgotten what Lange said about partnership and why Clark wouldn’t sign UN declaration.
Continue reading
Thomas Cranmer: Are political parties too tribal?
Assessing the impact on democracy and the escalation of polarisation
Political parties play a significant role in democratic systems, including in New Zealand. They provide a means of organising political representation and facilitating the functioning of the government. However, the question arises whether political parties, with their inherent tribalism and policy conformity, are necessary for a functioning democracy. The shortcomings of political parties are apparent on an almost daily basis with elected representatives and supporters encouraged to maintain a blind support for party policies even when faced with legitimate criticism. The adversarial nature of the Westminster system makes it difficult for politicians to admit mistakes and the net effect is an exacerbation of polarisation.
Continue reading
Callum Purves: A lesson in co-governance from Northern Ireland
This month marks the 25th anniversary of the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement that brought peace to Northern Ireland. It ended a decades-long conflict between Irish Republicans and British Unionists.
As a relative newcomer to New Zealand and someone who spent time working in Northern Irish politics, I have noticed political parallels between the two. Both are dealing with issues such as addressing the wrongs of the past, the politicisation of language, upholding minority rights and the best form of governance to do this.
Continue reading
John Robinson: Our Choice For The Future: Equality Or Tribal Rule
John Robinson is a research scientist with two masters degrees (mathematics, physics) from the University of Auckland and a doctorate from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The focus of his work has been the longterm development of human society situation of Maori in New Zealand. on a finite planet (futures research) and the late 20th century social Familiarity with the lack of honesty in the Treaty process resulted in a deepening concern over the increase of racebased division. A first report on what was happening was in “The corruption of New Zealand democracy, a Treaty industry overview” (2011).
Continue reading
Eric Crampton: INFORMATION FAILURES
Voting for local government should be simple.
If you think that council has generally done a good job, support most incumbent candidates. Make sure to rank incumbents who generally supported the outcomes you prefer ahead of new challengers. Rank promising new challengers ahead of the few incumbents who supported things you oppose.
Continue reading
Bryce Edwards: Why New Zealand’s shift to a republic will be thwarted
The death of Queen Elizabeth and the ascension to the throne of King Charles has reignited the debate on whether New Zealand should become a republic. But despite strong arguments in favour of shifting to a republic, such a move is unlikely to occur anytime soon.
What will stop the republican movement from gaining ground and winning over a majority of New Zealanders to ditch the monarchy? The answer is Treaty politics.
Continue reading
Gary Judd QC: Lawyers must reject co-governance and coercion
New Zealand is faced with a determined push for a momentous political change called co-governance, but really a devolution of power to an unelected tribal elite who have been described in Cabinet papers as ‘iwi/Māori’. Giving powers of veto and more, co-governance will enable iwi/Māori to impose their will on the ordinary people of New Zealand. Chris Trotter’s Co-governance: New Zealand’s own Catch-22 in LawNews (Issue 10) argues that we should surrender to coercion and avoid violent revolution. I say co-governance is wrong and surrender to coercion is wrong, but we should thank Chris Trotter and LawNews for unveiling the agenda.
Continue reading